A board member questioned your compensation. Here's how to respond with data.
When a board member questions compensation, the instinct is to justify. The better response is to show the data. ExemptPay generates a Board Confidence Report using 3.27 million IRS Form 990 compensation records — so your answer is backed by the same public filings anyone can look up.
Reports start at $149. Minutes, not weeks.
How It Works
Enter your details
Title, total compensation, state, and budget size
We find your peers
Matched against 3.27M compensation records from IRS Form 990 filings
Get your report
Board-ready PDF with benchmarks, variance analysis, and discussion language
Frequently Asked Questions
How should a nonprofit board respond when executive compensation is questioned?
The strongest response is data. Boards should show compensation was set using a documented process with comparability data from similar organizations by budget size, geography, and mission. The IRS rebuttable presumption provides the framework.
What data should boards use to benchmark nonprofit executive compensation?
IRS Form 990 filings are the most comprehensive public source, containing actual reported compensation for every tax-exempt organization's officers and key employees. ExemptPay aggregates 3.27 million of these records.
What is the IRS rebuttable presumption of reasonableness?
A safe harbor: if a board uses comparability data, documents the basis for its decision, and ensures independence of decision-makers, compensation is presumed reasonable unless the IRS proves otherwise.
Can a board member's compensation concern become a legal issue?
Yes. Excessive compensation can trigger intermediate sanctions — a 25% excise tax on the executive and potentially 20% on approving board members. Documented comparability data significantly reduces this risk.
How can we prevent compensation challenges from catching us off guard?
Establish an annual compensation review before your fiscal year starts. Boards that benchmark proactively — and keep a current report on file — can respond to any question immediately with documented data. The strongest position isn't a good answer to a hard question; it's having the documentation already in place when the question arrives.
Related Resources
- Nonprofit Salary Benchmarks — See what comparable organizations actually pay their executives
- Compensation Documentation — Generate compensation documentation with peer benchmarks and board-ready language
- 990 Compensation Defense — Put your public 990 compensation in context with peer benchmarks
- See a Sample Report — Preview the Board Confidence Report format before you buy
- Pricing — Compare report tiers and features